November 30th SwiftHack Updates

This entry was posted by Josh Monday, 30 November, 2009

As always, the full Swifthack Scandal: What You Need to Know document can be found here.

In the statements from scientists section:

Marine-Mammal Biologist Peter Watts:

Science doesn’t work despite scientists being asses. Science works, to at least some extent, because scientists are asses. Bickering and backstabbing are essential elements of the process. Haven’t any of these guys ever heard of “peer review”?

There’s this myth in wide circulation: rational, emotionless Vulcans in white coats, plumbing the secrets of the universe, their Scientific Methods unsullied by bias or emotionalism. Most people know it’s a myth, of course; they subscribe to a more nuanced view in which scientists are as petty and vain and human as anyone (and as egotistical as any therapist or financier), people who use scientific methodology to tamp down their human imperfections and manage some approximation of objectivity.

In the pieces of general interest section:

Changes in the Weather

On “ClimateGate”

The Manufactured Doubt Industry and the Hacked Email Controversy

Using Karl’s Trick To Hide The Consensus

ClimateGate: Addressing the ‘Not a Hacker’ Meme

With ‘ClimateGate,’ Some Republicans Embrace Thug Politics

The Global Warming Emails Non-Event

Climate Science Data Sources

Tell it to the Ice Caps